Economists tell students and others that there are "needs" and "wants". And the distinction is subjective and personal for most people. "I need a drink." Likewise, who knows which are "essential services."? Politicians, of all people?
The news have been full of examples of questionable calls by various politicians on this question. Daycare? Essential for many working parents. "Green" Teslas? Essential for "Greens"?
The even tougher questions involve how and where and when.
"Fatal conceit" is a wonderful two-word gem. "Central planning is hard work" is too wordy. Both refer to the obvious fact that most knowledge is beyond the ken of politicians. This is one reason why we want to limit their powers. And why we rely on trial-and-error experimentation by people with "skin in the game" to figure things out.
Does the governor of California know what is essential for 40-million Californians? With the best of intentions, he cannot know. By now, he should know that not all individuals are equally at risk, not all environments are equally risky and that heavy doses of humility are in order.
My favorite local retailer has a special line for the over-60 folks.Fine. Perhaps require them to wear masks. Even take their temperature if you like. Let the over-60s and all others decide if they want to shop at such a place. My favorite grocers and my favorite restaurants have never given me food poisoning. They know their business.
The list goes on. Publish common-sense guidelines (even though they are well known) if you must. But rely more on common sense choices than what politicians prescribe.
CORRECTION
Body temperature not enough. Face masks and social distancing until we are past the crisis.
The news have been full of examples of questionable calls by various politicians on this question. Daycare? Essential for many working parents. "Green" Teslas? Essential for "Greens"?
The even tougher questions involve how and where and when.
"Fatal conceit" is a wonderful two-word gem. "Central planning is hard work" is too wordy. Both refer to the obvious fact that most knowledge is beyond the ken of politicians. This is one reason why we want to limit their powers. And why we rely on trial-and-error experimentation by people with "skin in the game" to figure things out.
Does the governor of California know what is essential for 40-million Californians? With the best of intentions, he cannot know. By now, he should know that not all individuals are equally at risk, not all environments are equally risky and that heavy doses of humility are in order.
My favorite local retailer has a special line for the over-60 folks.Fine. Perhaps require them to wear masks. Even take their temperature if you like. Let the over-60s and all others decide if they want to shop at such a place. My favorite grocers and my favorite restaurants have never given me food poisoning. They know their business.
The list goes on. Publish common-sense guidelines (even though they are well known) if you must. But rely more on common sense choices than what politicians prescribe.
CORRECTION
Body temperature not enough. Face masks and social distancing until we are past the crisis.
Posts
